Consumer Reports Reveals Top Reliable Car Brands for Used Vehicles

by AutoExpert   |  10 September, 2024

Share :

So, hаve you ever seen those ads clаiming, "The best new cars mаke the best used cars"? Well, it turns out there's а bit of truth behind the hype. Consumer Reports decided to put that ideа to the test recently by checking out which car brands hold up best over time, and their findings? Pretty much what you'd expect if you've been keeping an eye on car brands.

They asked their reаders about all the troubles they've had with their cars from the last five years, covering everything from minor аnnoyances to big repair headaches. With feedback on over 150,000 vehicles, they really got a comprehensive look at what's out there. Then, they averaged out the reliability scores to figure out which brands are the real deal.

Used Vehicles

And who topped the list? Lexus and Toyota. No surprise there, right? They've pretty much been the poster children for reliability. Mazda came in third, which isn't too shabby either.

Used Vehicles

Here’s how the top ten rounded out:

  • Lexus: Leading the pack with a 75 out of 100.
  • Toyota: Close behind at 72.
  • Mazda: Not too far off with 59.
  • Acura: Solid at 57.
  • Honda: Keeping up with 55.
  • Buick: Doing okay at 47.
  • BMW and Subaru: Both tied at 46.
  • Nissan: Just a point behind at 45.
  • Mercedes-Benz: Bringing up the rear with 43.

Used Vehicles

The survey didn’t just count up the issues; it really dug into various problems, from small stuff like interior trim breaking to big concerns like EV battery failures or engines needing expensive repairs outside of warranty. Lexus and Toyota did great, showing why fewer problems really count in keeping them ahead of the game.

Used Vehicles

Consumer Reports’ senior automotive data analyst shed some light on why these brands do so well. Apparently, companies like Lexus and Toyota don’t rush into redesigns. They prefer slow and steady improvements, which helps their cars stay reliable long-term. It’s kind of a "slow and steady wins the race" approach that really works.

Used Vehicles

But it's not all roses for everyone. Tesla, Dodge, and Chrysler were at the bottom of the list. Tesla, interestingly, does well with new cars but seems to struggle with keeping that momentum in the used market.

Used Vehicles

So, if you're thinking about a used car and want something that'll last without giving you a headache, sticking with brands known for their dependability might just be your best bet. Go find that perfect ride and enjoy the journey!

Top News

Recomended:

Car Limp Mode vs. EV Turtle Mode: Causes & 2026 EPA Updates - Photo
Others
Car Limp Mode vs. EV Turtle Mode: Causes & 2026 EPA Updates

Over the years, car companies figured out they needed to idiot-proof engines and transmissions. Limp mode is their answer. When something breaks, the car basically hobbles itself on purpose so things

AutoExpert
The Chevy Stovebolt Six: The 72-Year Legacy of the
Others
The Chevy Stovebolt Six: The 72-Year Legacy of the "Cast-Iron Wonder"

Nobody at Chevrolet actually named it the Stovebolt. When the inline six-cylinder showed up in 1929, gearheads took one look at those slotted bolts holding the pushrod covers and oil pan together and

AutoExpert
The Heavy Truth: Why Your 2026 Car Probably Has an Aluminum Hood - Photo
Others
The Heavy Truth: Why Your 2026 Car Probably Has an Aluminum Hood

Cars are getting heavier every year, and there's no sign of it stopping. The EPA has been tracking this since the early '80s, and new vehicles just keep adding more weight. Electric batteries,

AutoExpert
Michelin vs. Uniroyal: The Tire Satisfaction Report Is Out - Photo
Others
Michelin vs. Uniroyal: The Tire Satisfaction Report Is Out

Buying tires is one of those boring grown-up chores that nobody enjoys. It costs a lot, it feels confusing, and once they’re on the car, most people are just hoping they did not make a bad cho

AutoExpert
Toyota Tundra vs. The World: Which Truck Reaches 250,000 Miles? - Photo
Others
Toyota Tundra vs. The World: Which Truck Reaches 250,000 Miles?

People love to argue Ford vs. Chevy when it comes to trucks. But if the question is “which one is most likely to still be running at 250,000 miles,” the answer is… Toyota Tundra.

AutoExpert
100-Car Michigan Pileup: How to Survive a Winter Highway Nightmare - Photo
Tips & Tricks
100-Car Michigan Pileup: How to Survive a Winter Highway Nightmare

Over 100 cars just smashed into each other in Michigan. Don't let this be you.Winter driving already sucks enough without worrying about getting caught in one of those insane multi-car pileups

AutoExpert
Stop Driving Like It’s 1995: 5 Habits You Need to Quit in 2026 - Photo
Tips & Tricks
Stop Driving Like It’s 1995: 5 Habits You Need to Quit in 2026

Modern cars have changed. Your driving habits should too.Cars today are nothing like the ones people learned to drive on 20 or 30 years ago. They've got sensors everywhere, computers handling

AutoExpert
The Physics of the Flip: What Does That Tab on Your Rearview Mirror Do - Photo
Video
The Physics of the Flip: What Does That Tab on Your Rearview Mirror Do

It's not decoration; it's saving you from getting blinded at night.Most people have driven past that little tab on their rearview mirror a thousand times without really thinking about what

AutoExpert
Green is the New Gray: The Global Car Color Report Is Out - Photo
Others
Green is the New Gray: The Global Car Color Report Is Out

The car color situation is still depressing, but there's a tiny glimmer of hope.Car colors have been boring as hell for years now. Everyone just buys white, black, or gray like we're livin

AutoExpert
90 Years of the Chevy Suburban: History, Hollywood, and Specs - Photo
Others
90 Years of the Chevy Suburban: History, Hollywood, and Specs

Seriously, what's it going to take to kill this thing? The Suburban hit 90 this year. That's insane. Your great-grandparents could've bought one new. And here we are in 2026 and Chevy

AutoExpert