Too Much Oil in Your Car's Engine: Risks and How to Fix It

by AutoExpert   |  22 August, 2024

Share :

Ever topped off your car's engine oil and wondered if you might have added a bit too much? Sure, we often hear warnings about not letting the oil dip too low, but overdoing it can actually stir up trouble under the hood too.

When More Isn’t Merrier

Imagine the engine as the heart of your car, with every part designed to work in near-perfect harmony. Now, these parts need just the right amount of oil—no more, no less. So, what happens if you get a little heavy-handed with the oil can? Let’s say it’s not going to make your engine any happier.

Too Much Oil

Checking the Oil: Not Just a Tick Box Exercise

Here’s a quick tip on checking your oil: Warm up your car, shut it down, and give it about 15 minutes to chill. This wait lets the oil settle back down where it belongs, giving you a clear read on what’s really going on in there.

Why Precision Matters with Engine Oil

Your engine's insides are pretty finely tuned. Tiny clearances mean there's no room for error. Any extra gunk, like dirt or debris—or in this case, too much oil—can throw a wrench in the works. And since many engines now are made of aluminum, they're especially vulnerable. They love to keep cool but can get dinged up easier than the old steel ones.

Too Much Oil

The Troubles of Too Much

Overfill your oil, and the excess can whip up into a foamy froth. Not only does this look less appealing than your favorite cappuccino, but it also does a lousy job at keeping things smooth inside. Components wear out faster, and you might even see your trusty oil pump throw in the towel—ouch.

What’s That Light on My Dashboard? Yep, that could be your engine complaining about the oil overload. Too much of it makes it tough for the engine to keep up its rhythm, possibly leading to a lit-up check engine light and even misfires. Not exactly what you want when you’re about to hit the road.

Too Much Oil

Leaks and Pressure Spikes: The Slippery Slope of Too Much Oil Packing your engine with extra oil cranks up the internal pressure, which might sound good to some, but it’s actually a fast track to leak city. Seals can give way, and before you know it, you’ve got oil spots marking your usual parking spot.

Got Too Much Oil? Let’s Fix That

If you peek at the dipstick and the oil’s riding high, here’s how to fix it:

  1. Get your car on a flat spot and pop open the hood.
  2. Pull out the dipstick, give it a wipe, and slide it back in for a double-check.
  3. If it’s clear you’ve overdone it, either let some out from the bottom by loosening the drain plug just a touch, or get fancy with a syringe and hose to suck some out through the dipstick tube.

Too Much Oil

Keeping It Balanced

Going overboard with engine oil is an easy mistake but keep it within the safe marks to avoid turning your engine into a high-drama zone. Just right means a smooth-running engine that lasts longer and performs better. Remember, in the world of engine oil, balance is key—too little or too much, and your car won’t be shy about letting you know.

Top News

Recomended:

Car Limp Mode vs. EV Turtle Mode: Causes & 2026 EPA Updates - Photo
Others
Car Limp Mode vs. EV Turtle Mode: Causes & 2026 EPA Updates

Over the years, car companies figured out they needed to idiot-proof engines and transmissions. Limp mode is their answer. When something breaks, the car basically hobbles itself on purpose so things

AutoExpert
The Chevy Stovebolt Six: The 72-Year Legacy of the
Others
The Chevy Stovebolt Six: The 72-Year Legacy of the "Cast-Iron Wonder"

Nobody at Chevrolet actually named it the Stovebolt. When the inline six-cylinder showed up in 1929, gearheads took one look at those slotted bolts holding the pushrod covers and oil pan together and

AutoExpert
The Heavy Truth: Why Your 2026 Car Probably Has an Aluminum Hood - Photo
Others
The Heavy Truth: Why Your 2026 Car Probably Has an Aluminum Hood

Cars are getting heavier every year, and there's no sign of it stopping. The EPA has been tracking this since the early '80s, and new vehicles just keep adding more weight. Electric batteries,

AutoExpert
Michelin vs. Uniroyal: The Tire Satisfaction Report Is Out - Photo
Others
Michelin vs. Uniroyal: The Tire Satisfaction Report Is Out

Buying tires is one of those boring grown-up chores that nobody enjoys. It costs a lot, it feels confusing, and once they’re on the car, most people are just hoping they did not make a bad cho

AutoExpert
Toyota Tundra vs. The World: Which Truck Reaches 250,000 Miles? - Photo
Others
Toyota Tundra vs. The World: Which Truck Reaches 250,000 Miles?

People love to argue Ford vs. Chevy when it comes to trucks. But if the question is “which one is most likely to still be running at 250,000 miles,” the answer is… Toyota Tundra.

AutoExpert
100-Car Michigan Pileup: How to Survive a Winter Highway Nightmare - Photo
Tips & Tricks
100-Car Michigan Pileup: How to Survive a Winter Highway Nightmare

Over 100 cars just smashed into each other in Michigan. Don't let this be you.Winter driving already sucks enough without worrying about getting caught in one of those insane multi-car pileups

AutoExpert
Stop Driving Like It’s 1995: 5 Habits You Need to Quit in 2026 - Photo
Tips & Tricks
Stop Driving Like It’s 1995: 5 Habits You Need to Quit in 2026

Modern cars have changed. Your driving habits should too.Cars today are nothing like the ones people learned to drive on 20 or 30 years ago. They've got sensors everywhere, computers handling

AutoExpert
The Physics of the Flip: What Does That Tab on Your Rearview Mirror Do - Photo
Video
The Physics of the Flip: What Does That Tab on Your Rearview Mirror Do

It's not decoration; it's saving you from getting blinded at night.Most people have driven past that little tab on their rearview mirror a thousand times without really thinking about what

AutoExpert
Green is the New Gray: The Global Car Color Report Is Out - Photo
Others
Green is the New Gray: The Global Car Color Report Is Out

The car color situation is still depressing, but there's a tiny glimmer of hope.Car colors have been boring as hell for years now. Everyone just buys white, black, or gray like we're livin

AutoExpert
90 Years of the Chevy Suburban: History, Hollywood, and Specs - Photo
Others
90 Years of the Chevy Suburban: History, Hollywood, and Specs

Seriously, what's it going to take to kill this thing? The Suburban hit 90 this year. That's insane. Your great-grandparents could've bought one new. And here we are in 2026 and Chevy

AutoExpert