Pedestrian Accidents: Who's At Fault? It's Complicated.

by AutoExpert   |  31 July, 2025

Share :

So someone's walking across the street, gets absolutely demolished by a car, and now everyone's arguing about whose fault it was. Spoiler alert: it's way messier than you'd think.

People Are Getting Killed Out There

Look, 76,000 pedestrians get smashed by cars every year. That's insane. In 2017, almost 6,000 people died just trying to get to the other side of the road. We're talking 16 people a day getting killed for basically walking.

Pedestrian Accidents

And get this - California, Florida, Texas, New York, and Arizona? They're responsible for nearly half these deaths. I mean, they've got tons of people and traffic, so that tracks. But here's the weird part: almost all the most dangerous states are in the South. New Mexico's the absolute worst, then Florida and South Carolina. Nobody really knows why Southern states are death traps for pedestrians, but the stats don't lie.

Every State Makes Up Their Own Rules

States are freaking out about all these deaths and passing random laws left and right. Problem is, nobody can agree on anything.

Minnesota went completely nuts - if there's a pedestrian anywhere in the road, cars have to stop. Period. Doesn't matter where. Meanwhile, down in Louisiana, drivers only have to care if the person's on their side of the street. Other side? Not their problem.

Massachusetts says stop if someone's within 10 feet of your car. Other places only care if they're in your actual lane. It's like every state just threw darts at a board to decide their laws.

Pedestrian Accidents

Back in the Day Was Different

Used to be pedestrians and drivers had the same rights. Nobody got special treatment. Those days are long gone. Now most places baby pedestrians, especially at crosswalks, but every state does it differently because why would anything be simple?

Generally, cars are supposed to yield at marked crosswalks and stop signs. But if some genius decides to cross in the middle of nowhere? Good luck with that.

Your Phone Will Get You Killed (Maybe)

This is where things get stupid. Cities everywhere are making it illegal to look at your phone while crossing the street. Honolulu completely lost their minds and banned even glancing at your phone while walking. Like, what if you're checking the time?

There's this thing called a "textalyzer" that cops want to use to see if drivers were texting before crashes. Don't want to hand over your phone? Kiss your license goodbye, just like refusing a breathalyzer.

Here's the kicker though - only like 7% of people who get killed were actually distracted by their phones. Most of the time it's drivers being idiots or not paying attention. But sure, let's blame the person walking.

Pedestrian Accidents

Blind People Get Special Treatment (Sometimes)

If someone's got a white cane, that's a whole different game. Some states make drivers slam on the brakes, others just want you to be extra careful, and some places don't give a crap. Because consistency is apparently too much to ask for.

What It All Means

The whole "blame the pedestrian" thing is pretty much dead. Laws keep shifting more responsibility onto drivers, which honestly makes sense. A car weighs like 3,000 pounds - it's gonna win every time against some person just trying to cross the street.

Pedestrian Accidents

So if someone gets hit, don't just assume they screwed up because they weren't in a car. The rules are changing fast, and drivers are expected to actually pay attention now. Crazy concept, right?

Recomended:

Those Black Dots Around Your Windshield Have Been Hiding Several Important Jobs - Photo
Others
Those Black Dots Around Your Windshield Have Been Hiding Several Important Jobs

They run around the edge of almost every modern windshield: a solid black border that gradually breaks into smaller and smaller dots before disappearing into clear glass.Most drivers have stared t

AutoExpert
Your Tire Pressure Rose on the Highway. Put the Gauge Down Before Letting Air Out - Photo
Tips & Tricks
Your Tire Pressure Rose on the Highway. Put the Gauge Down Before Letting Air Out

The sticker inside the driver’s door says 35 PSI. After an hour on the highway, the dashboard says 39. Four extra pounds of pressure sounds like a problem. The tires were set correctly that morn

AutoExpert
Your Fresh Engine Oil Turned Black Already. Should You Be Worried? - Photo
Others
Your Fresh Engine Oil Turned Black Already. Should You Be Worried?

Fresh motor oil is reassuring stuff. It pours from the bottle in a clear amber stream, looking clean enough to belong in a kitchen rather than an engine.A few hundred miles later, the dipstick can

AutoExpert
The 2027 Toyota Tundra Gets The Upgrade It Needed Most - Photo
Car News
The 2027 Toyota Tundra Gets The Upgrade It Needed Most

Hoping to boost the Tundra's appeal, Toyota has introduced new features and a new Trailhunter model for 2027.Designed for overlanding enthusiasts, the new Trailhunter package is based on the S

AutoExpert
That Tiny Slot Beside Your Shifter Has a Job Most Drivers Never Discover - Photo
Others
That Tiny Slot Beside Your Shifter Has a Job Most Drivers Never Discover

A dead battery is annoying in any parking space. It becomes considerably more awkward when the car is nose-first inside a garage and the tow truck needs it in Neutral.The brake pedal feels normal.

AutoExpert
The “B” on Your Hybrid Shifter Does Not Mean Battery, Boost or Better Economy - Photo
Others
The “B” on Your Hybrid Shifter Does Not Mean Battery, Boost or Better Economy

Park, Reverse, Neutral and Drive need little introduction. Then there is B. It sits on the shifter of many hybrids looking important but refusing to explain itself. Battery seems like the obvious

AutoExpert
There Is Moisture Inside Your Headlight. Do You Actually Need a New One? - Photo
Others
There Is Moisture Inside Your Headlight. Do You Actually Need a New One?

The car comes out of the wash looking excellent, apart from one headlight. Behind the clear lens is a patch of mist, as though someone breathed on the inside of it. The other lamp may be perfectly

AutoExpert
Mercedes-Maybach Just Made Its Flagship SUV Even More Luxurious - Photo
Car News
Mercedes-Maybach Just Made Its Flagship SUV Even More Luxurious

Luxury SUVs have become the vehicle of choice for many ultra-wealthy buyers, and Mercedes-Maybach wants to make sure they don't have to compromise. The new 2027 Mercedes-Maybach GLS 680 takes ever

AutoExpert
Geely Says The Galaxy TT Doesn't Need A Huge Battery To Go 450 Miles - Photo
Car News
Geely Says The Galaxy TT Doesn't Need A Huge Battery To Go 450 Miles

A big battery isn't always the answer. Geely believes the smarter approach is building a more efficient electric drivetrain, and that's exactly what it has done with the upcoming Galaxy TT. Th

AutoExpert
Nissan Says Brake Caliper Colors Actually Mean Something - Photo
Car News
Nissan Says Brake Caliper Colors Actually Mean Something

Think brake caliper colors are just there to look good? Nissan says they actually serve a purpose. According to the automaker, the color behind the wheels acts as a quick visual guide, revealing the t

AutoExpert